Human approval gate
A human approval gate is a point in an agent workflow where the agent must stop and a person must act before the work continues. Nicholas Hopper places the gate at the one irreversible action in a workflow and lets agents do everything before it unattended.
Where Nicholas Hopper puts the gate
Hopper’s rule is to find the single action in a workflow that cannot be undone and gate only that. In his design for an agent-run job search, that action is sending email. Scheduled, unattended runs may label threads, file them and write drafts, but they may never send. The design states the reason directly: sending is the only irreversible, outward-facing, reputation-bearing action in the system.
The rule is written to override any conflicting instruction in any other document or prompt. An agent that can send but cannot draft is told to skip the item and flag it in its run summary.
This system is a design. Hopper wrote its operating documents and decision log, and it has not yet been run.
Related rules from the same design
- Low confidence never takes a terminal action. An uncertain item gets an “action needed” label and stays in the inbox. It is never closed on a guess.
- Nothing is deleted. Removing an item from the inbox means archiving it.
- Every run ends with a written summary that lists drafts created, marked “none sent”, and the items that need a human decision.
In production
At APX Stream, Hopper built a multi-agent planner and executor in which human approval gates sit between the agent’s proposed answers and anything that leaves the system.